The U.S. national team suffered a heavy defeat to Italy, creating the possibility that it could fail to advance to the quarterfinals despite a 3-1 record.
The United States lost 6-8 to Italy on the 11th (Korea time) in the 2026 World Baseball Classic (WBC) Pool B fourth game at Minute Maid Park in Houston, Texas. With this loss, the United States finished the first round with a 3-1 record.
After finishing as runner-up to Japan in the final of the last tournament, the United States assembled a star-studded roster so luxurious it was called the strongest team in history for this tournament. Superstars from both pitching and hitting, including Aaron Judge (Yankees), a two-time consecutive American League MVP, Paul Skenes (Pittsburgh), Tarik Skubal (Detroit), Karl Kalle (Seattle), and Bobby Witt Jr. (Kansas City), among others, joined the national team.
Early in the tournament, the United States showed the overwhelming performance expected of the top favorite. In its opening game on the 7th, it routed Brazil 15-5, and on the 8th it won a 9-1 victory over Great Britain. On the 10th, after a close game with Mexico, it won 5-3 to reach three victories.
With three wins secured, the United States looked likely to advance to the quarterfinals, but the situation began to grow complicated as Italy and Mexico showed better-than-expected performances. Both Italy and Mexico easily notched two wins by defeating Great Britain and Brazil, and Italy caused a major upset by beating the United States to reach three wins.
Currently in WBC Pool B, Italy is first with three wins, the United States (3-1) is second, and Mexico (2-1) is third. Fourth-place Great Britain (1-3) and fifth-place Brazil (0-4) have already been eliminated from the quarterfinals. Because of the loss to Italy, the United States can no longer advance to the quarterfinals on its own. Whether it advances will be decided by the result of the final game between Italy and Mexico.
The permutations are as complicated as they were for South Korea, which advanced to the quarterfinals in dramatic fashion. Competing with Taiwan and Australia for a quarterfinal spot, South Korea beat Australia 7-2 in the final game to overcome the narrow set of conditions requiring a victory by two runs or fewer allowed and by a margin of five or more runs to reach the quarterfinals.
The United States' fate depends on the Italy-Mexico game. If Italy wins, the scenario is simple: Italy goes unbeaten to finish first in the group, and the United States advances as the group's second-place team.
If Mexico wins, the permutations become complicated. The United States, Italy and Mexico would all be tied at 3-1, requiring application of tiebreaker rules. The first priority is head-to-head among the three teams, but because each team would be 1-1 against the others, the next criterion is the lowest runs allowed rate (runs allowed/defensive innings).
The United States has already logged 18 innings and 11 runs allowed over two games, fixing its runs allowed rate at 0.611. Allowing eight runs in the Italy game was painfully costly. Based on nine innings, if Mexico allows five runs or fewer and Italy allows four runs or fewer, the United States will be eliminated from the quarterfinals. Conversely, if Mexico allows six or more runs and Italy allows five or more runs, the likelihood that the United States advances increases.
If Mexico allows six runs and Italy allows five runs, they would match the United States' 18 innings and 11 runs allowed. In that case, the tiebreaker moves to the lowest earned run average (earned runs/defensive innings). Of the United States' 11 runs allowed, eight are earned. Therefore, if tied, the United States would likely advance. Mexico would need to record six runs allowed with two earned runs or fewer, and Italy would need to record five runs allowed with one earned run or fewer to advance.
If Mexico allows seven or more runs and Italy allows six or more runs, the United States could advance without calculating earned runs. If either condition is met, the United States would finish second in the group; if both teams engage in high-scoring games satisfying both conditions, there remains a chance the United States could finish first in the group.
The United States is indisputably the world's strongest baseball team in name and reality, but it has struggled to produce strong results in the WBC. It failed to reach the final in the 2006, 2009 and 2013 tournaments, and it was not until 2017 that it won its first title. In the 2023 tournament, it fell to Japan led by Shohei Ohtani (Dodgers).
Having vowed revenge and assembled such a star lineup that it was called the "earth's defense force," the world's baseball fans are watching with keen interest to see whether the United States will be shockingly eliminated in the first round and fail to reach the quarterfinals, or whether it will advance and get a chance to make up for the shock of this loss.
[OSEN]